So, about that mappers only forum.
Moderator: Moderators
So, about that mappers only forum.
The mappers-only forum gets next to no usage; is there really a need to keep it?
Re: So, about that mappers only forum.
IMO change this forum to release/preview only, and change the other forum to map making (questions, tuts) move the sticky's in here about map making to the other forum and make that other forum open.
-
SirArtturi
- Posts: 1164
- Joined: 23 Jan 2008, 18:29
Re: So, about that mappers only forum.
This could be a good solution...Hoi wrote:IMO change this forum to release/preview only, and change the other forum to map making (questions, tuts) move the sticky's in here about map making to the other forum and make that other forum open.
Re: So, about that mappers only forum.
Merge the map mappers forum into the regular map forum.
Creating that subforum was a stupid idea to start with.
Creating that subforum was a stupid idea to start with.
Re: So, about that mappers only forum.
i want to be able to comment on map releases
+1 to zwzsg's suggestion. or maybe 2 subforums with posting access for everyone, one for discussion, and one for complete maps. +1 to hoi's suggestion, minus the whole confusing forum switchup thingy
+1 to zwzsg's suggestion. or maybe 2 subforums with posting access for everyone, one for discussion, and one for complete maps. +1 to hoi's suggestion, minus the whole confusing forum switchup thingy
Re: So, about that mappers only forum.
confusing?
this forum just for releases and comments.
the other forum about mapping itself, so how to make maps, ect.
seems pretty clear to me
this forum just for releases and comments.
the other forum about mapping itself, so how to make maps, ect.
seems pretty clear to me
Re: So, about that mappers only forum.
with mild forum name changes...
you're right! it is better! +1 to hoi's idea!
you're right! it is better! +1 to hoi's idea!
Re: So, about that mappers only forum.
The real issue is that the mappers forum is private iirc. Only mappers can post there.
I would agree with merging the two, as the other forum doesnt really see any use.
I would agree with merging the two, as the other forum doesnt really see any use.
Re: So, about that mappers only forum.
make it non private, and for map making only, then thi one for releases and comments on maps and we're done.
Re: So, about that mappers only forum.
I made some maps and never felt any need to join a private mappers club...what is it for anyway...
Re: So, about that mappers only forum.
Forbodding couldn't stand my criticism of his maps, so he requested a forum where I (despite having released maps long before him him) could not post. Yep, the sole purpose of that mapper-only forum was to protect Forbodding soft skin from my complaint about how he should lern2tile instead of releasing 80mb maps.Gota wrote:...what is it for anyway...
Even though mods are way more complicated than maps, you don't see more that one mod forum, right?
Re: So, about that mappers only forum.
Despite numerous requests I never got access even though I had maps on my machine Id built. Numerous threads went by where I had an answer but was powerless as I watched them all discuss to hell the problem.
As a result people just used this forum instead.
As a result people just used this forum instead.
Re: So, about that mappers only forum.
I still disagree on the tiling thing.
-
Forboding Angel
- Evolution RTS Developer
- Posts: 14673
- Joined: 17 Nov 2005, 02:43
Re: So, about that mappers only forum.
Sigh. Idiotic post is idiotic.zwzsg wrote:Forbodding couldn't stand my criticism of his maps, so he requested a forum where I (despite having released maps long before him him) could not post. Yep, the sole purpose of that mapper-only forum was to protect Forbodding soft skin from my complaint about how he should lern2tile instead of releasing 80mb maps.Gota wrote:...what is it for anyway...
Even though mods are way more complicated than maps, you don't see more that one mod forum, right?
That is not the reason it was created. It was created for a good purpose, but ended up essentially being unnecessary, but still contains some great information.
One of the reasons it was created was because we had a problem with 0 moderation and people shitting up map question threads.
Zwzsg, shut up about tiling. The compiler does not use tiles in the way you think it does. FFS, make a map even a crappy one to see what I mean.
Last edited by Forboding Angel on 01 Mar 2009, 22:26, edited 1 time in total.
Re: So, about that mappers only forum.
Could you?
+1 to Hoi's suggestion anyway.
Wait, what.
+1 to Hoi's suggestion anyway.
Wait, what.
Re: So, about that mappers only forum.
Yes sometimes I have good ideas.
Re: So, about that mappers only forum.
and for that I give you cookie, all rejoice!Hoi wrote:Yes sometimes I have good ideas.
Re: So, about that mappers only forum.
super duplicate cookie beam! now I have 2! yay! *eats*
Re: So, about that mappers only forum.
I already made a couple 0.5 mb maps.Forboding Angel wrote:Zwzsg, shut up about tiling. The compiler does not use tiles in the way you think it does. FFS, make a map even a crappy one to see what I mean.
-
Forboding Angel
- Evolution RTS Developer
- Posts: 14673
- Joined: 17 Nov 2005, 02:43
Re: So, about that mappers only forum.
Thank you for proving my point.
Anyway, yeah go ahead and merge them or something. By this point it fails to matter anyway.
Edit: BTW z that was not me saying your map sucks, I'm saying that VISUALLY it sucks. It may play like win and god, but I (and prolly most of the spring playerbase) wouldn't be playing on it often (if at all) because it's freaking ugly.
I'm not insulting you here, I just telling you that the compiler is a crappy compiler, the tiles you speak of are dds tiles and have little to do with the actual texture you use. If you use a repeating texture, fine, the compiler will do a fairly decent job of using the same tiled texture over and over again, but your map will look like assflakes.
Anyway, yeah go ahead and merge them or something. By this point it fails to matter anyway.
Edit: BTW z that was not me saying your map sucks, I'm saying that VISUALLY it sucks. It may play like win and god, but I (and prolly most of the spring playerbase) wouldn't be playing on it often (if at all) because it's freaking ugly.
I'm not insulting you here, I just telling you that the compiler is a crappy compiler, the tiles you speak of are dds tiles and have little to do with the actual texture you use. If you use a repeating texture, fine, the compiler will do a fairly decent job of using the same tiled texture over and over again, but your map will look like assflakes.